New claim about non-citizens voting in Iowa raises questions
We should be cautious
After Barack Obama won the 2008 Iowa caucuses, there were rumors floating around.
The record turnout of 240,000—a previously unheard-of figure—prompted worries that out-of-state voters had crossed the border and voted in the caucuses. Some of that finger-pointing was aimed at Scott County.
There were stories at the time that buses had suddenly come from Illinois with new voters the night of the caucuses.
As the political reporter for the Quad-City Times, I decided to check it out. I got a list of the voters who had registered the day of the caucuses from the Scott County auditor’s office. There were a whole lot of names. I then took a random sample—also a fairly large number, as I recall—and I checked them against an Iowa Department of Transportation database.
A surprisingly large number of these new voters didn’t check out. I wondered: Could the rumors be true?
To be clear, the rumors were not true.
I dug deeper, and after some time-consuming investigation, which involved other sources, too—as well as some shoe leather visiting the homes of these newly registered voters—I found they were legitimate. There was no story there. As I recall, there was only one person in my sample that I could not locate.
One of the lessons I learned from this experience: Databases can be deceiving.
This experience came to mind when I read news articles this week that said Iowa Secretary of State Paul Pate’s office reported that 87 people had voted in the state, then subsequently told the Iowa DOT they were not citizens; in addition, another 67 people registered to vote but did not cast ballots, then afterward told the DOT they were not citizens, either, the office said.
Pate said he turned over the 154 names to the Iowa attorney general’s office and the Iowa Department of Public Safety for potential prosecution.
I have no idea whether the data at issue here is accurate or not. My experience teaches me to be cautious. I learned that in 2008. The Des Moines Register also reported that Joe Enriquez Henry, political director for the League of United Latin American Citizens of Iowa, said it is possible some voters who were flagged as non-citizens by the DOT may, in fact, be citizens but because of language barriers, did not understand the agency’s form.
Pate’s news release also said that they discovered 2,022 people who reported they were not citizens, and after that, they voted or registered to vote. These people may have become citizens before they registered or voted, according to the secretary of state’s office.
They will be required to vote a provisional ballot this year, which means they must prove their eligibility to a special board of review before their ballots can be counted.
Obviously, it is not legal for non-citizens to register or to vote in Iowa. And if these people knowingly broke the law, they should be held to account. I have no doubt this is something Attorney General Brenna Bird would surely pursue. After all, Bird has made it abundantly clear she supports the rule of law—unless, of course, the criminal is Donald Trump.
Whatever the outcome, I believe in the overall integrity of Iowa’s election system. The number of people who have been proved to have illegally voted in Iowa is small. And even if all 87 of the people that Pate flagged had voted illegally, it still would amount to a relatively insignificant number. There are 2.3 million voter records in the Iowa voter file, meaning the 87 represent one out of every 26,000. (It is important to note it is not clear when these 87 people are said to have voted. The state list goes back to the year 2000.)
Ultimately, I hope this development, coming as it does less than two weeks before Election Day, doesn’t discourage people who have a right to vote from going to the polls.
The leaders in this state talk a lot about making sure that only eligible voters cast ballots, and they can be quite threatening about it, too. That’s bound to worry people who may not speak the language well or who aren’t sure about the rules. And, as we know, the state Legislature has come up with a whole lot of new rules when it comes to voting.
Ultimately, the goal should not only be to ensure that only the eligible can vote in our elections, but we should also make sure that those who are eligible aren’t afraid to do so.
Our weekly podcast
The Iowa Down Ballot podcast is now available. I was the host this week, so I’d encourage you to give it a listen. Laura Belin, Art Cullen, Bob Leonard, Kathie Obradovich and I talked about a range of topics, from debates to the perils of polling to lawsuits.
Iowa Down Ballot is a production of the Iowa Writers’ Collaborative.
Thank you, WVIK radio and Kai Swanson
I had a great time on WVIK radio’s “Saturday Morning Live” program with Kai Swanson last week. We talked about politics, how to find good news sources and our favorite columnists, among other topics.
You can find the podcast here.
This is the second time that Kai, a subscriber to this newsletter, has asked me to appear on the program, and I have been most grateful for the opportunity.
The Office Lounge is open on Friday
Lastly, I want to draw your attention to the monthly “Office Lounge” meeting, which will occur on Friday, Oct. 25, at noon.
This gathering, via Zoom, is open to all paid subscribers to Along the Mississippi, as well as to other newsletters that are part of the Iowa Writers’ Collaborative.
During the meeting, we hear from the Collaborative’s writers, as well as our readers, and it invariably makes for a lively discussion. If you’re a paid subscriber—or if you decide to upgrade your subscription today—please join us.
For paid subscribers, I have put the link to the call at the bottom of this post.
Along the Mississippi is a proud member of the Iowa Writers Collaborative. Please check out the work of my colleagues and consider subscribing. Also, the collaborative partners with the Iowa Capital Dispatch, which provides hard-hitting news along with selected commentary by members of the Iowa Writers Collaborative. Please consider making a donation to support its work, too.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Along the Mississippi to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.