Iowa unfairly targeted hundreds of people in last year's election
More evidence the state engaged in a reckless abuse of power
The State of Iowa unfairly targeted hundreds of potential voters during last year’s election, and it just released more evidence to prove it.
Two weeks before the 2024 election, Secretary of State Paul Pate ordered local election officials to challenge the votes of about 2,200 people who were placed on a secret list. These people at one point in the past had told the Iowa Department of Transportation they were noncitizens but were registered to vote, and the state was worried they might not be eligible.
At the time, there was clear evidence Pate was using flawed data. The DOT database is a notoriously unreliable tool for finding noncitizen voters, which we already knew was a rare occurrence, anyway. But in the heat of a contentious election and shortly after a conversation with Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds, Pate used the power of his office to target hundreds of potential Iowa voters.
On Thursday of last week, Pate admitted that only 277 of the 2,176 people on his list were confirmed to be noncitizens.
That’s nearly 13%. Or 1 out of 8. Predictably, there was no apology given to the other 87%. (That 277, by the way, represents roughly 0.01% of all registered voters in the state of Iowa. And according to the Des Moines Register, the “vast majority” of those 277 didn’t try to vote or even register to vote in 2024.)
Still, Pate told local election officials last October they were to stop nearly 2,200 people from voting like everybody else. Instead, local auditors’ offices were told to require them to cast provisional ballots. That meant to get their vote counted, unfairly targeted citizens would have to prove later on that they were citizens—if they chose to go to the extra effort.
Naturally, voters were intimidated. This was entirely predictable. Numerous studies have shown that when hurdles are put in front of people during elections, those who are targeted tend not to vote as often as others.
What’s more, this voter suppression scheme was aimed at finding phantoms—the rare noncitizen who votes in Iowa.
Pate declared last week they’d found 35 noncitizens who voted in the 2024 election.
If this number is accurate, it’s a barely noticeable sliver of the more than 1.67 million Iowans who cast ballots last fall.
What this means essentially is that, in the entire City of Davenport, there was perhaps one noncitizen who voted. Add in Bettendorf, Blue Grass, Buffalo, Eldridge, Long Grove, Walcott, LeClaire, Princeton, Riverdale, McCausland, Donahue, Dixon, New Liberty and the rest of Scott County—along with Dewitt, Dewitt Township and half of Camanche in Clinton County—and there was one other.
At this point, columnists like me are supposed say, it’s wrong for anybody to vote illegally. And that is true. But I’m just as worried, if not more so, about the 1,900 potential voters who at the last minute were recklessly put on Paul Pate’s secret list for unfair treatment.
How many of these people said, “it’s not worth the effort to vote if I have to go to the trouble to find my papers and then go back to the auditor’s office? I’m a citizen, why go through the hassle when others don’t have to?
How many who might not understand English well said, “I don’t know what this means, but I’m not going to bother, either.”
How many who came here from repressive countries said, “this sounds all too familiar. I’m staying home.”
I worry about these people.
Is there anybody running state government in Iowa concerned about them? It doesn’t look like it.
I know many people will shrug at the idea that somebody they don’t know has to go to additional effort to get their ballot counted. But, of course, these are the same people who will never be asked to shoulder this additional burden. They have the luxury of knowing that they will never have to confront this kind of discrimination at the ballot box.
Republicans have conditioned Iowans for years to be frightened of the thought that even one immigrant might illegally cast a ballot. For every illegal vote cast, a legal one is invalidated, they say. But they don’t care about the people who are intimidated into not voting because of the reckless use of state power. Never do they consider how many votes are denied because of such abuses by the government.
Pate said last week that his office used the federal Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements database to confirm his figures. But why did he wait so long to try to check this database? He blamed the Biden administration last year for his failure to get access to this tool, but other states, like Virginia, had the foresight to act months earlier.
Other states even gained access to the SAVE database years ago.
Why didn’t Iowa move earlier, too? Why did Iowa wait until almost the last minute to embark on this process?
Why did Pate issue such an aggressive order only to partially back off before a federal judge heard a challenge to the order—but after many of the people on his list had been unfairly targeted? After some already had surely been dissuaded from exercising their right to vote.
The politicians who run this state like to complain about government overreach, but they will ignore these questions. And Iowa Attorney General Brenna Bird said last week Iowa law enforcement will investigate the cases Pate identified.
But what will the rest of us do?
I have a suggestion: Perhaps Iowans who believe government ought to treat all people fairly should ask themselves how many of their fellow citizens were discouraged from voting last year by a reckless and overzealous state?
We’ve heard for years about the relative few who vote illegally. But many Iowans rarely, if ever, consider how many people lose their vote through the government’s aggressive abuse of power. I don’t know what that number might be, but do you suppose it’s greater than 35?
It’s time for the Office Lounge
This Friday the Iowa Writers’ Collaborative will host its once-monthly Office Lounge, the Zoom meeting for paying subscribers, where they get the opportunity to hear from members of the collaborative, and to ask questions and offer ideas. Here is the link to the meeting, which will be held on March 28 at noon.
Along the Mississippi is a proud member of the Iowa Writers Collaborative. Please check out the work of my colleagues and consider subscribing. Also, the collaborative partners with the Iowa Capital Dispatch, which provides hard-hitting news along with selected commentary by members of the Iowa Writers Collaborative. Please consider making a donation to support its work, too.
Thanks for the sunshine, Ed.
In addition, some of these people probably never try to vote again.